Why Economic Times Mutual Fund Rating Sucks ?

India’s leading financial daily, The Economic Times [09-Feb] has come up with a Rating on Mutual Funds. The ratings suck and we advise our readers who want to create wealth over long term not to follow the same.

Economic Times analyst rate, SCAM tainted and PSU influenced SBI as the best fund house. It has ranked 4 funds from the SBI stable at Platinum rank and none from Reliance Mutual Fund or Franklin Templeton India.

Also the best performing mutual fund in the Indian market which is the single largest fund organically grown and consistently performed, HDFC Equity Fund is missing out of the ranking.
Some Reliance Funds are slightly bigger in size of corpus than HDFC equity but they are all raised through New Fund Offering.

Their is no mention of Reliance Growth Fund, Reliance Vision Fund or Franklin Templeton Prima and Franklin Templeton Bluechip fund which are so far the best managed large diversified equity funds in the Indian market.

Kotak Maintains BUY on AIA Engg

Irrespective of what happens with the CRR, Kotak Securities has retained BUY rating on AIA Engineering with a price target of Rs 1520, 18% upside from current levels. AIA Engineering has reported good Q3FY07 results, which were in line with analyst estimates.

AIA Engg’s expansion plans are on track. The company plans to increase its capacities from 65,000 TPA to 115,000 TPA by end of March-2007 and increase rise further to 165,000 TPA by October-2007. To cater to the demand of mill internals, the company is setting up another 100,000 TPA plant for manufacturing high chrome mill internals.

The company has an order book of Rs 3.7 bn of which 55% is for exports.

AIA Engg is expected to earn EPS of Rs 52, 76 and 101 for FY07, FY08 and FY09 respectively. The price target for AIA Engineering is Rs 1520.

MindTree Consulting Subscribed 103 Times

BSE and NSE finally shutdown their systems at midnight and till then they had received 577662585 bids against an offer of 5593300 subscribing the MindTree issue 103 times. We had a blind subscription rating on MindTree IPO.

The retail portion of the issue is subscribed by 30 times. The fate of Rs 1 Lakh application by retail investor will also be decided by lottery in the ratio of 1:2. Here is the breakup of subscription.

Category No.of shares offered/reserved No. of shares bid for No. of times of total meant for the category

Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIBs) 2964445 465359745 156.9804

Non Institutional Investors 494075 66679710 134.9587

Retail Individual Investors (RIIs) 1482220 44548665 30.0554

Cinemax listed on NSE today and the shares closed below the offer price. DalalStreet.Biz had an expensive rating on the issue. I wouldn’t BUY as the Great Indian Multiplex story is melting down.

RBI Hikes CRR by 0.5% to 6%

With the Indian inflation at record high, 6.58 %, the Finance Minsitry had no other option but to cool the overheated economy. The Reserve Bank of India, just minutes ago announced the hike in Cash Reserve Ratio by 50 bps to 6%. This hike would suck Rs 14,000 crore away from the system.

In order to manage short term liquidity crisis, RBI has proposed the CRR hike in two phases with the second phase to come into effect after Budget on March-3rd.

RBI in a press release said,

It may be recalled that in the Third Quarter Review of the Annual Statement on Monetary Policy for the year 2006-07, the stance of monetary policy was set out. The Review inter alia stated :

“Hence, a determined and co-ordinated effort by all to contain inflation without unduly impacting the growth momentum is not only an economic necessity but also a moral compulsion. To the extent the current inflationary pressures are attributable to monetary conditions, it is essential to undertake appropriate measures, in continuation of those already taken and in the light of anticipated developments.” (paragraph 77)

SBI CFO said that the lending rates will increase not just to the overheated Real Estate borrowers but also to all other borrowers. Banking stocks will be under pressure and the market correction is likely to continue tomorrow.

Bear Hugs Dalal Street

The sensex has fallen close to 600 points in 3 trading sessions. Infrastructure & Real Estate stocks are the worst hit. Brokers attribute the correction due to the rise in interest rates and also their is a widespread speculation that some of the concessions given to Infrastructure sector linked to lands banks will be withdrawn in the current budget.

Capital Goods and Cement stocks are also amongst the top losers. Auto stock is driving in the reveres gear as well. FII interest in the market has been lackluster but they have been selectively picking stocks.

The IPO market is also expected to cool down and markets are expected to be volatile until the budget.